Miss K: Pizza pot pie = amazing! Reasonably priced. We shared a large chef salad, flatbread & a large pizza between 3 ppl & it was plenty. Also, they don't accept cards, so make sure you bring enough cash
Jillian Jackson: The pinot noir and pizza pot pie is perfect for date night
A: One of my favorite places in Chicago, Mediterranean bread so yummy! And the pizza pot pie super delicious!
6. Marge's Still
8.2
1758 N Sedgwick St (at W Willow St), Chicago, IL
Bar · Old Town Triangle · 24 tips and reviews
Michael Binetti: Menu is really good. All burgers, pot pie, tuna steak, portobello sandwich. All really good.
Molly E: I always walk passed by here and finally went in! They have a great Bloody Mary, burger and chicken pot pie. I was very impressed with the food and overall selection. Should have gone sooner!
Don Hilliker: Chicken pot pie is the best.
8. Petterino's
7.8
150 N Dearborn St (at Randolph St), Chicago, IL
Italian Restaurant · The Loop · 62 tips and reviews
Melanie V: Free valet after 7pm! Plus, enjoy 3 course meal for $19.95 also after 7! Chicken pot pie, ftw!
Matthew Supert: Try the Chicken Pot Pie - Excellent chicken pot pie made with puff pastry. Peas, carrots and asparagus.
Christina R: Best restaurant service ever! This was a perfect spot for a relaxing dinner to catch up with my hubby after a long week. Mussels, gnocchi, pot pie, and creme brûlée were all amazing. New Chicago fav
10. Lady Gregory's
8.6
5254 N Clark St (at W Berwyn Ave), Chicago, IL
Irish Pub · Andersonville · 152 tips and reviews
Mightybytes: Kick back Lady Gregory’s relaxing library room while sipping one of over 300 whiskeys on their menu, or nibbling on a sophisticated grilled cheese sandwich, pot pie, or shepherd’s pie. Read more.
bartend4fun: The Chicken Pot Pie made my day!
Merrie Bunt: They're on my short list for best chicken pot pie in the city!
11. Grand Lux Café
8.3
600 N Michigan Ave (at Ontario St), Chicago, IL
American Restaurant · Streeterville · 349 tips and reviews
Lynda: Love their Chicken Pot Pie (it's HUGE and delicious) and their Strawberry Shortcake....have never had anything like it in my life. It's the shit!
Lauren-Ashley Barnes: Very affordable, huge portions, you always end up taking some home. The chicken pot pie is great and the salads are really good. The best seats are by the windows looking out on N. Michigan ave.
Lynda: Best chicken pot pie in the planet. Make sure you share this bc it's huge!!
13. Sepia
8.4
123 N Jefferson St (btwn W Washington St & W Randolph St), Chicago, IL
New American Restaurant · West Loop · 63 tips and reviews
Lauren Drogos: The vegetarian options are very limited, but the root vegetable pot pie was unique and yummy!
Janet Johnson: a classic Bombay sapphire martini comes in a classic coupe. and it is simply delicious.
Time Out Chicago: The winner: the Sepia Mule, the bar’s take on the Moscow Mule, made with ginger-infused vodka for a spicy-yet-refreshing sip: http://tmoutchi.us/13EV7jr Read more.