1. Levain Bakery
9.3
167 W 74th St (at Amsterdam Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 857 tips and reviews
Meli: most amazingly delicious cookies you can possibly eat. They look like scones but weigh like a brick. The Raisin Oatmeal & the dark chocolate chocolate chip cookies are must tries! Add milk! $4/each
Ben Lerttuangsitthisiri: The lines are a tad long but worth the wait for perfection. The choc walnut is the clear winner but their oatmeal is very good as well.
Carollyn Philip: Often overlooked, the fresh from the oven, Oatmeal scone is delicious.
2. Java Girl
7.8
348 E 66th St (btw 1st Ave & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Coffee Shop · Upper East Side · 57 tips and reviews
Dewon Ramdew: Oatmeal smoothie is heavenly!
Allison Clayton: The Oatmeal Smoothie is a nice surprise: hot, creamy, and slightly sweet; very unique! Not too often you drink your oatmeal on the way to work in the morning...
Aarthi D.: Oatmeal smoothie with almond milk: it's like drinking a bowl of delicious, creamy oatmeal. Better than it sounds by a mile.
3. Levain Bakery
9.3
351 Amsterdam Ave (at W 77th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Upper West Side · 84 tips and reviews
Chelsea Murray: Oatmeal raisin is a must!
Carissa: i’m a cookie snob, and these are unique and so so amazing. crispy outside and gooey inside. i got the chocolate chip walnut and oatmeal raisin. split with a friend so you can try both, it’s worth it!
Elisa: Oatmeal raisin ftw. This branch has more space inside for lining up compared to the one on 74th. Yes, the lineup is worth it.
Antonio D'souza: Irish oatmeal makes a great breakfast. For lunch go with portobella press.
Gina Seghi: No one has mentioned the BAKED OATMEAL! oh Christ it's good. Served in a bowl of warm milk and sliced strawberries. The best oatmeal you will have, and such a great idea to bake it.
Nureen Gulamali: The Irish Cut Oatmeal is perfect for a cold rainy day! Add a bit of nutmeg, cinnamon, and maple syrup for perfection.
Darren: Baked oatmeal for breakfast. Seared tuna salad for lunch. Done!
Kaitlin Villanova: Baked oatmeal, just do it. Also this is a great spot for meetings b/c it can be over coffee, tea, snacks beer or wine, it's a winwin
Jacqueline Wilde Kurdziel: The baked oatmeal is incredible. Definitely big enough for 2 people to split, too.
10. Pause Cafe
9.2
3 Clinton St (btwn E Houston & Stanton St), New York, NY
Juice Bar · Lower East Side · 128 tips and reviews
Ginger Stanley: Must have: Oatmeal pecan chocolate chip cookies!!
Vivienne Gucwa: Their gluten free oatmeal is awesome. They will add in most fruits (berries, apples, bananas), walnuts, and even agave if you want.
Olof Viktorsdottir: The apple, orange, ginger, lemon juice is super refreshing!
Ingeborg Volan: Really good coffee, and good oatmeal too.
Lauren Hansen: Dig the place itself, super cute. But the coffee was meh, and the oatmeal chocolate chip cookie was super dry and really not good at all.
Julia Xiao: Homemade Chai lattes are the best! So is the baked oatmeal bar which is just the right amount of moist chewy goodness! My weekend go to 👍🏻
Maya Jain: Must- the oatmeal cookie shot $5. Dessert in a glass
Kyle Siskey: This place is great. The bar tenders are quick and friendly. Lewis and the guys get it done. The oatmeal cookie shot is awesome, even if you're a dude. Tell Steph and Meliss- the roomates- I said hi.
Anna Santiago: Favorite low key bar. Old school east village, authentic and hidden gem. Good for when you just want to chill.