Shake Shack is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

1. Shake Shack

9.1
Madison Square Park (Madison Ave & E 23rd St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · NoMad · 1236 tips and reviews

Anna R.Anna Riego: I got the black and white shake with a reg cheeseburger. Burger was fantastic (so juicy) and the shake was rich and creamy. Yum! Check out the web-cam on the site to see how long the line is! Read more.

Joon L.Joon Licopit: burgers, fries, shakes, everything all gooood!

Andrew L.Andrew Lam: Tony Bourdain-approved burgers and shakes (try the black & white). This location, in Madison Square Park, is my fave but be prepared to wait in line 1 hour+, especially on nice days around lunch.

Shake Shack is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

2. Shake Shack

8.8
691 8th Ave (at W 44th St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 855 tips and reviews

Mike K.Mike Kelleher: If it's your first visit gotta try the shack burger, cheese fries and black and white shake, yummy!

JenniferJennifer: Great food and great service! Try their shack burger and black and white shake!

Brandon D.Brandon Dickerson: Delicious custard-based milkshakes. Burgers are also good.

Harlem Shake is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

3. Harlem Shake

8.0
100 W 124th St (at Lenox Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Central Harlem · 175 tips and reviews

jillian d.jillian dino: The burgers are delicious - similar to the patty at shake shack. Be sure to try the salted caramel shake!

New York PostNew York Post: Retro diner makes a big splash uptown with thick red-velvet milkshakes, classic burgers of rich, flavorful beef, buttermilk-brined chicken sandwiches (classic $7.50, jerk-style $8.50) and hot dogs. Read more.

Noel S.Noel Simmonds: I love the tasty (and unique) burger selection and the shakes are off the chain. Great place for lunch or dinner.

Black Tap is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

4. Black Tap

8.6
529 Broome St (btwn Thompson & Sullivan St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · SoHo · 222 tips and reviews

jasmine j.jasmine jefferson: The food is amazing! Makes you want to go to sleep and the milkshakes are to die for. Try and come early they open at 11:30am so the wait isn't as long

Yasmina B.Yasmina Backström: Best Burgers & milkshakes in the city

Deven M.Deven Marte: I thought the Texan Burger would be greasy- It was not! Incredibly juicy, and the bacon was prime cut! Paired with a super cookies & Cream milkshake 😍😋

Max Brenner is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

5. Max Brenner

8.6
841 Broadway (btwn E 13th & E 14th St), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · Greenwich Village · 676 tips and reviews

Immi G.Immi Gaga: Food came out fast. Good service. Their waffle fries are awesome. The really cheesy mac and cheese is true to it's name! The hazelnut milkshake is so good. Portions look sort of small but is filling.

Abigail K.Abigail Koffler: The turkey burger is delicious and all good meals end with a milkshake

Rohit Chandra B.Rohit Chandra Bajaj: Superb place, love the white chocolate cheesecake crepe, white hot chocolate, the melting chocolate truffle heart cake n shake ....Very nice and a must visit if you drool over the word chocolate :)

Milk Bar is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

6. Milk Bar

7.8
251 E 13th St (at 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Dessert Shop · East Village · 711 tips and reviews

Kathryn Y.Kathryn Yu: Boozy milkshakes are awesome. Cereal Milk White Russian, anyone?

AmandaAmanda: Birthday Cake Truffles! I call them Unicorn Poop. Also love their Fancy Milkshakes (ice cream + vodka)...slurp.

Wes G.Wes Güity: Get the Cereal Milk Shake!

Schnipper's is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

7. Schnipper's

7.7
620 8th Ave (at W 41st St), New York, NY
Comfort Food Restaurant · Theater District · 313 tips and reviews

SeamlessSeamless: A favorite lunch spot at Seamless HQ. While their burgers and shakes are not to be missed, the salads and sandwiches are also real winners. Oh and their delivery is super fast!

Ashley S.Ashley Southall: Their milkshakes bring all the boys to the yard, especially the cookies and cream or the salted caramel. For food, try the Hickory Bacon Bleu burger and sweet potato fries with maple dipping sauce.

Tim M.Tim McDonald: Salted caramel shake is amazing!

Bareburger is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

8. Bareburger

8.2
535 Laguardia Pl (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Greenwich Village · 193 tips and reviews

Michael A.Michael Aloe: Great all organic menu! Burgers are great! Panko covered chicken strips with five dipping sauces are delish! Love the pistachio milk shake!

Official H.Official Hank: Best burgers! Best milk shake! Best patio!

Frank R.Frank Rimalovski: Really excellent burgers w more types of meats than typical (elk, bison, etc). Great fries & shakes too. Service was not great last time but made it up w free fries & drinks. (3 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more.

Bareburger is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

9. Bareburger

7.7
514 3rd Ave (30th), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Rose Hill · 146 tips and reviews

m.g.m.g.: Wow so delicious - bison burger, fries with curry ketchup and special sauce, top off with a milkshake. Awesome

eMoofeMoof: Bison hamburger - very recommended, & also the chicken. The peanut butter & chocolate milkshake is absolutely amazing!

FredericFrederic: Very good burger & milkshake but very noisy restaurant !

Burger Joint is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

10. Burger Joint

8.4
119 W 56th St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 782 tips and reviews

Philippe A.Philippe AZOULAY: One of the best burgers in town with Shake shake and Five Guys

jayme d.jayme del Rosario: Hidden place in Le Parker Meridien Hotel. Look for the neon burger sign by the lobby's curtains and follow your nose! One of the best burgers, fries and shakes in town. They have beer, too.

Douglas S.Douglas Souza: You can't go wrong: cheeseburger + fries + choc shake. Undeniable one of the best in town!

Ellen's Stardust Diner is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

11. Ellen's Stardust Diner

8.2
1650 Broadway (at W 51st St), New York, NY
Diner · Theater District · 449 tips and reviews

Crystal G.Crystal Goh: Food is absolutely terrible, but singing waitstaff are an absolute joy to watch. Also serves strong and pretty delicious alcoholic milkshakes and warm drinks.

bri9ettbri9ett: chocolate shakes are the best-not too milky or too sweet, make it a mudslide & it's on. salmon is always cooked perfectly. get brownies to go (heaven!). have fun w/live ent by the singing waitstaff!

Shatisha B.Shatisha Bryant: Great milkshakes. Yumm

The Counter is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

12. The Counter

7 Times Sq (btwn 41st & 42nd St.), New York, NY
Burger Joint · Theater District · 230 tips and reviews

Scott K.Scott Kelson: Peanut butter + chocolate + kahlua and a dash of baileys = my "adult" milk shake of choice - best served at the Counter's counter

Matthew G.Matthew Gramza: Get the spiced apple pie milkshake!

Janyce P.Janyce Pre: Kind of got jipped out of my newbie special, but the food is delicious nonetheless. Definitely try the Birthday cake shake!!

Lexington Candy Shop Luncheonette is one of The 13 Best Places for Milkshakes in New York City.

13. Lexington Candy Shop Luncheonette

7.8
1226 Lexington Ave (at E 83rd St), New York, NY
Diner · Upper East Side · 86 tips and reviews

Nat H.Nat Harward: Classic Strawberry. Blending Bassetts Ice Cream of Philadelphia’s classic vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and coffee shakes since 1925. You'll feel like you've been transported to a soda fountain. Read more.

Dil R.Dil Ribeiro: The sandwiches are fantastic and the milkshake is superb.

Clémentine T.Clémentine TiPanda: Delicious milkshake ❤️