The Hayes Theater is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

1. The Hayes Theater

8.9
240 W 44th St (btwn 7th Ave & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Theater · Theater District · 38 tips and reviews

Eelain S.Eelain Steketee: jello shots, waiter service, and my favorite show on Broadway. sing along to the tunes and jump up and down.. have fun!

David C.David Campbell: Jello shots sold at your seats

Laura Lee M.Laura Lee Mills: This show is awesome! The talent of the entire cast is unbelievable.

Bob's Your Uncle is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

2. Bob's Your Uncle

8.4
929 Columbus Ave (btwn W 105th & W 106th St), New York, NY
Bar · Upper West Side · 14 tips and reviews

Chris C.Chris Corey: Staff was excellent. Bartender gave us a free jello shot and a great rec for dinner afterwards.

A L E XA L E X: Super friendly staff, great beer selection, not overly crowed, spacious and very welcoming.

Ron H.Ron Hsu: Really great local bar that isn’t too loud.

The Meatball Shop is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

3. The Meatball Shop

64 Greenwich Ave (at Perry St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · West Village · 273 tips and reviews

Savannah P.Savannah Peterson: French 75 Jelly Shots are quite possibly the best ever. Pairs well with everything!

Minhee C.Minhee Cho: The specials do not disappoint! Had a "Bees Knees" jello shot to start the night and it was absolutely delicious. The market salad was fresh+crisp and the Merguez balls were perfectly spiced.

LilitherapyLilitherapy: Special: pizza meatball Delicious!!

The Meatball Shop is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

4. The Meatball Shop

200 9th Ave (btwn W 22nd St & W 23rd St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Chelsea · 191 tips and reviews

Tim J.Tim Julien: try the market Jello Shot

Akshata K.Akshata Kalia: One of my favorite places. They have jello shots! Ice cream sanwiches are amazing and so are the meatballs

Mikey N.Mikey Neff: Go with the spicy meatball sliders with parmesan cream sauce!! Super cute little place!!

Lois is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

5. Lois

98 Avenue C (btwn E 6th & E 7th St), New York, NY
Wine Bar · Alphabet City · 55 tips and reviews

OliOli: Red wine jello shots!

Madeline R.Madeline R: Super cool idea, a bunch of interesting affordable wines on tap. Amazing date vibe.

Emily K.Emily Kane: Many wines. On tap. Many cheeses. On plates. (For real though, get a cheese plate.)

Underballs is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

6. Underballs

200 9th Ave (btwn W 22nd & W 23rd St), New York, NY
Speakeasy · Chelsea · 8 tips and reviews

Pam B.Pam B.: Down a staircase at the back. You order your cocktails like you order your meatballs! Also, daily jello shots.

Jenn D.Jenn Day: Very cool speakeasy. Lots of fun. Great drinks.

Daniel P.Daniel Powell: Just okay - staff was friendly but it was mostly empty. The meatballs though...great every time

Asuka Sushi is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

7. Asuka Sushi

7.0
300 W 23rd St (btwn 9th Ave & 8th Ave), New York, NY
Sushi Restaurant · Chelsea · 101 tips and reviews

Ravi B.Ravi Batra: Great food great service! Trenfy atmposphere :) try the cloud 9 - spicy and delicious. they have fun jello shots with strong drinks. Oh and try the pork gyoza ;) yum

Patrick A.Patrick Abejar: Enormous portion tasty portion sizes for a good price! The bento boxes are delicious and a really good deal.

MatthewMatthew: Don't sit next to the bathroom.

South Street Seaport is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

8. South Street Seaport

8.8
South St (Pier 17), New York, NY
Harbor or Marina · Financial District · 224 tips and reviews

@A2ThaR@A2ThaR: Got to make sure your lady does the jello shots.

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Tons of tourists here but still a great destination for shopping, eating, and drinking. Our favorite spot down here still remains Beekman Beer Garden.

Gossip GirlGossip Girl: Catch N before he sails into the sunset on his boat, The Charlotte. Or go with him—he’s been known to take impromptu trips (and even more impromptu guests) around the island. Read more.

Henrietta Hudson Bar & Girl is one of The 9 Best Places for Jello Shots in New York City.

9. Henrietta Hudson Bar & Girl

7.5
438 Hudson St (at Morton St), New York, NY
Gay Bar · West Village · 15 tips and reviews

The Corcoran GroupThe Corcoran Group: Great music and a packed dance floor filled with a diverse group of ladies (and men), good music and good drinks. Expect a $10 cover on the weekends.

Clare S.Clare Shepard: One of the best if not the BEST girl bar in NY :P. The staff here ROCK yay

NYC PrideNYC Pride: For girls who like girls, for girls who want to kick back, there's Henrietta Hudson. Attracts a diverse array of lady-loving ladies by offering up a simple, comfortable, unpretentious space.