Offering four types of patty, 12 types of cheese, 33 toppings, 21 sauces and six types of bun (think: English muffin), The Counter makes it possible to build exactly 312,120 different burgers.
Awesome - get the 1/3 beef burger on english muffin with horse radish cheddar cheese, Tobasco, corn and black beans, chipolte and anything hot. YUMMMMM!
As hard as it may be to believe, but this is decent food in Times Square! Lots of different options to choose from. I HIGHLY recommend getting the English Muffin for the bun & adding a fried egg.
very good breakfast spot with a lot of egg choices (as you would guess from the name 😁). Poached eggs on avo sandwich was good, and i heard it's even better with English muffin!
Fluffy eggs are hard to come by, but they nail it. Gluten free English muffins are delish, make your own egg sandwich and their sauces are amazing. Cozy, cute place.
Steak and egg sandwich was really good - delicious with a little spicy kick. I was also pleasantly surprised by the gluten free English muffin that I got it on - probably the best one I've ever had.
The bar is perfect if you are a party of one. And the veggie burger on an english muffin was excellent. Really great neighborhood spot.
Delicious French toast with nutella: 4.75/5 , penny egg sandwich with English muffin and sausage : 3.75/5
If they told u the croissant is not available for the penny sandwich don't go with the English muffin its not good just change the order & get something else
Wasn't quite sure about the cheeseburger served in an English muffin, but, that shit was delicious!
Comfortable and friendly place. Burgers are served on English muffins and are delicious! Could become a regular here.
Best spot for a beer and chill dinner on the UWS any time of year. Burgers are served on English muffins, try the lamb or turkey. Back room is cozy with the fire place, but caution it can get hot.
Bacon and cream cheese on a toasted English muffin will make you feel sprightly after too many cocktails the night prior.
They sometimes rush you, it's overwhelming to order. My go-to is a gyro with everything and add red onion. For breaky, get a bacon egg and cheese on an english muffin with hot sauce.
Great bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel. The sandwich guys also have great rapport with the regulars.
Try having the burger on a giant english muffin
Best turkey burger in the city, hands down! Get it on an English muffin too. You won't regret it. And their fries are perfectly done!
Loved the burger, i heard the turkey burger with an english muffin is excellent. Great environment to hang out with a friend or two.
get the French Onion Soup Burger!! a standard Pat LaFrieda patty with caramelized onions and a Gruyère bechamel (with delicate hints of Dijon), all on an English muffin
French Onion Soup Burger: In between two toasted English muffin lies a medium rare patty, topped with melted gruyere cheese, dijoin mustard and caramelized onions. Served with a side of crispy fries. Read more.
No frills dining in the Far West Village. Big fan of the tuna melt on english muffin.
Outdoor tables are lovely, staff is friendly, food is good. Watermelon salad was great. Gazpacho very good.
This tiny bar serves some of the tastiest cheese-based food in town. Try the calabro mozzarella sandwich, topped with mayo and pickles and served on an english muffin.
Awesome little dive with an awesome beer selection. Try the Brie and Blackberry jam grilled cheese. It is amazing.
Recommended dishes: Beer cheese; grilled mozzarella sandwich; grilled cheddar sandwich; Asian gnocchi and beef. Read more.
Great English muffins and good coffee too!
Get your oat milk lattes here! Great coffee and espresso drinks. The pastries are good too, and you can pick up a sandwich or snack for later.
Scrambled eggs with salmon and avocado toast was delicious! Can't say the same about cappuccino.
The place is pretty big but manages to create a sense of intimacy for each party. Check out the vodka cocktails, and the English muffin burger!
Great for brunch! Awesome menu and staff!
Cute neighborhood place that I find myself coming back to every week. Chill vibe, great beer selection and the kitchen has produced nothing but home runs so far, Uncle Tommy's Pie my personal fav.
Burgers on English muffins and beet and goat cheese salad
Coffee burger! Was majorly skeptical of the English muffin bun but it works! Also low carb? Alphabet City Ale is also solid.
Pretty terrific beer list. And love the food. The french dip sandwich is my favorite in NYC.
English muffin with ricotta and jam. Done.
Love all of it. Grab a bite of mushroom gouger, English muffin w ricotta&salmon. Indulge yourself w Maple crullers at the end. You'll want to come back again and again.
So much goodness! Broccoli melt and Malbec provided perfect respite from the chill.
The Original Chicken Sandwich and the Mac & Cheese
Remember to check your order before you leave,I’ve gotten two wrong orders!
Bathroom Code 062120
Amazing little gem in a fantastic location. Great and very friendly staff.
Great service and cutest nooks on the lobby floor
In a word, ‘quaint’.
Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA