1. Doughnut Plant
9.0
379 Grand St (at Norfolk St), New York, NY
Donut Shop · Lower East Side · 430 tips and reviews
Remington Guest: the coconut, creme brûlée and carrot cake are amazing. lavendar is strange but good. thru were sold out of the churro, which is supposedly amazing.
Dan Fleming: The carrot cake and blueberry donuts are amazing if you're looking for something different.
Emma W: Best doughnuts ever. Personal favorites are the Crème brûlée and the carrot cake.
3. Carbone
9.1
181 Thompson St (btwn Bleecker & W Houston St), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 243 tips and reviews
Sharon: Spicy Rigatoni, sweet corn polenta, carrot cake ! Must order!
JAMESON PINE: All the hype is for a reason! Great music and service. Charred octopus, spicy vodka rigatoni and carrot cake are all a must. Martinis too. Get there early and grab a drink at ZZ's Clam Bar!
Zan F: Spicy Rigatoni, Caesar Salad, Lemon Cheesecake, Carrot Cake
5. Carrot Top Pastries
8.0
3931 Broadway (btwn 165th & 166th St.), New York, NY
Bakery · Washington Heights · 40 tips and reviews
Daniela Italo: Amazing Carrot Cake. Sausage & Pepper sandwiches are great too!
Zulay Antonio: The salads here are so worth it because they are not anorexic they come with enough mixed greens and meats. The pastries are delicious top 3 are carrot cake strawberry cheesecake and red velvet
Dionne McLaughlin: If you have a sweet tooth, you must pop in to this place. Can't say they are big on customer service but the pastries are amazing, especially the carrot cake and carrot cupcakes.
6. Peacefood Cafe
8.5
460 Amsterdam Ave (82nd St), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Upper West Side · 218 tips and reviews
I Amos: Yes, the chickpea fries are delicious. But also, the tempeh avocado sandwich, and also also also the carrot cake.
James Mueller: GET THE CARROT CAKE, OR DIE TRYING
Daniel Schauenberg: The vegan cheeseburger and their carrot cake are both amazing
8. Magnolia Bakery
8.6
401 Bleecker St (at W 11th St), New York, NY
Bakery · West Village · 436 tips and reviews
Greg B.: The carrot cake is the best!
Tarsys Poterio: The best cakes, cupcake, and muffins, in town! Also ask for a piece of carrot cake and a glass of cold whole Milk...
Sarper Boz: Cupcakes are delicious; try the one with banana, carrot cake and pineapple.
Edmond Hilhorst: Carrot cake is yummy & huge
Serena W: PB&J cupcake was just right. Carrot cake is too dry - try Billy's cupcakes instead.
Jess Naldo: Everything is basically heaven in your mouth here: Pistachio, Dreaming Princess, Southern Red Velvet, and Carrot Cake. Wait is a bit long if there's a line so prepare to just stand there... Standing.
carol k: If you really like sweet, chocolate taste, try the pistachio tulip cup. Also try their carrot cake. They are my favorite (:
Patrick Baskin: Carrot cake & Oreo cookie cheesecake bites are to die for
Sarah P: EVERYTHING is good here! But the best are the cheesecake, carrot cake, and the cannolis.
13. Amy's Bread
8.5
672 9th Ave (btwn W 46th & W 47th St), New York, NY
Bakery · Hell's Kitchen · 267 tips and reviews
Erica: My friend is obsessed with the carrot cake which is deliciously buttery. I am a fan of the apple cider donuts!
PureWow: No surprise that the baked-goods geniuses at Amy’s make a mean carrot cake. And it’s packed with vitamin A under the cream-cheese frosting, so you can feel good about that extra slice. Read more.
PureWow: No surprise that the baked-goods geniuses at Amy's make a mean carrot cake. And it's packed with vitamin A under the cream-cheese frosting, so you can feel good about that extra slice.
inna kats: Carrot beet juice, hummus/babaganoush/falafel salad with chicken and carrot cake. Yummaaay
Miguel Lopez: Get the Bob's Plate or New Yorker Wrap. And -- an off-menu item -- the Chicken Pita Pizza. Save room for carrot cake slice.
Anthony: My sanctuary. Health conscious food that serves as fuel after a grueling workout. Large portions for reasonable prices. Try the chicken coop for a powerfully lean protein + carb meal.