Terri is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

1. Terri

60 W 23rd St (at 6th Ave), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 318 tips and reviews

Casey K.Casey Kitchens: The butterfinger shake is out of this world!

Chrissy L.Chrissy Lyn: The butterfinger milkshake is amazingly rich and delicious! Try the green juices, too.

Chris C.Chris Covell: Butterfinger shake is to die for!!!

Greecologies is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

2. Greecologies

379 Broome St (btwn Mott & Mulberry St), New York, NY
Café · NoLita · 139 tips and reviews

LorenLoren: I don't eat yogurt, but I honk I'll be back for the beautiful workspace, back garden, and halvah -- theirs is oddly like a fancy butterfinger filling with a hint of honey and citrus

Esha A.Esha Agarwal: Love the yogurt! Try the rose one

Andrei K.Andrei Kryssov: Delicious butter aka bulletproof coffee. Has a unique taste because they make their own butter. Refreshing if you are used to the kerrygold version. It also has mct oil so it will get you amped!

Sedutto is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

3. Sedutto

8.4
1498 1st Ave (btw 78th and 79th St), New York, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · Upper East Side · 45 tips and reviews

Nina L.Nina LoSchiavo: Fantastic ice cream and great flavor selection. Try the salted caramel or mint chip.

Jason L.Jason Lancaster: Peanut butter crunch. Tastes better than you thought possible.

Adam O.Adam Oliveri: Birthday cake is pretty amazing

Blossom Du Jour is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

4. Blossom Du Jour

617 9th Ave (btwn W 43rd & 44th St), New York, NY
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Hell's Kitchen · 68 tips and reviews

Kit I.Kit Ingui: Blossom butterfinger shake is ridiculously good. Loved the Little Italy as well!!

Shannon S.Shannon Spaniol: Just had the yummy scramble wrap and a side of tempeh bacon. Yum! :)

Gigi M.Gigi Monroe: Most amazing hot cakes with peanut butter agave maple syrup and tempeh sausage!

Blossom Bakery is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

5. Blossom Bakery

7.8
174 9th Ave (21st Street), New York, NY
Bakery · Chelsea · 13 tips and reviews

7th.List7th.List: Yesterday was opening day for this new Chelsea bakery. On the menu are raw, vegan, organic and gluten-free baked goods. Our new favorite pastry, the kouign-amann, is also on offer. Read more.

Ethan t.Ethan the Vegan: Seriously, THE. BEST. BAKERY. EVER! Vegan or not, why go anywhere else??

Rob KRob K: Friendly staff and delicious (and dairy-free) baked goods, but a small coffee and cookie will sadly set you back about 6 bucks.

16 Handles is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

6. 16 Handles

7.5
153 2nd Avenue (btwn E 9th & 10th St), New York, NY
Frozen Yogurt Shop · East Village · 134 tips and reviews

Wolfe M.Wolfe Mikelic: Nice staff. Beautiful room with skylights in the back. Get the chocolate hazelnut crunch sauce. Really good.

Matthew R.Matthew Rathbone: watch peoples faces when they find out that their small yogurt is heavy enough to cost $9

Lauren L.Lauren Lachs: Straight dudes looking for love: hang around here from 7 to 10 on weeknights. If at first you don't succeed, bring a puppy.

Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe is one of The 7 Best Places for Butterfingers in New York City.

7. Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe

9.0
342 E 11th St (btwn 1st & 2nd Ave), New York, NY
Bakery · East Village · 317 tips and reviews

Joyce K.Joyce Kimsington: Italian cheesecake, spumoni, dark chocolate cake = so good! Cannoli =not my fav.

Jay S.Jay Shaw: Don't come here if you're on a diet. If you do come here while on a diet, be prepared to question your motives on what makes you happy in life.

Untapped CitiesUntapped Cities: The Café where, in 'Curb Your Enthusiasm' Larry stops in Veniero’s to buy a French baguette that he would eventually use to beat a man attacking Ricky Gervais in the NY subway. Find out more: Read more.