Cold Stone Creamery is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

1. Cold Stone Creamery

8.4
1316 S Halsted St, Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · University Village - Little Italy · 13 tips and reviews

AngelinaAngelina: Love the ice cream! Conveniently located a block away from UIC!

Kendra T.Kendra Torres: Add a brownie to your ice cream, make it taste great.

Jamie M.Jamie Marshall: Birthday cake remix!!!!!

Pop's Italian Beef & Sausage is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

2. Pop's Italian Beef & Sausage

7.5
10337 S Kedzie Ave, Chicago, IL
Fast Food Restaurant · Mount Greenwood · 9 tips and reviews

Alisa M.Alisa M: Their soft serve is amazing!

Colonel M.Colonel Mustard: How do you screw up a Chicago Hot Dog don’t steam the bun and it cold. They seem to change the cashier position weekly and it always get screwed up

Colonel M.Colonel Mustard: Having been raised by Johnanies Beef in Elmwood Park. Pop’s at 103rd and Kedzie surpasses Johnies Beef. Better tasting beef and great gravy and a super combo is like you died and went to heaven.

Scooter's Frozen Custard is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

3. Scooter's Frozen Custard

9.2
1658 W Belmont Ave (at Paulina St.), Chicago, IL
Ice Cream Parlor · Lakeview · 60 tips and reviews

Jennifer K.Jennifer Karum: Our friend Jess took us to this place and recommended the coconut custard. Incredible. I tried the banana Reese's (Elvis) got a small and was dying. Best custard ever

Amanda R.Amanda Ruzin: Get the concrete of the month; they're always good.

Time Out ChicagoTime Out Chicago: Order a Boston shake, and quiver in awe as the towering milkshake topped with hot fudge and whipped cream is handed over.

The Lifeway Kefir Shop is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

4. The Lifeway Kefir Shop

1745 W Division St (at N Wood St), Chicago, IL
Smoothie Shop · East Ukrainian Village · 18 tips and reviews

AkitaAkita: Make sure you try The Diva and Detox! They are both my favorites!!

ManlyDeal C.ManlyDeal Chicago: Mmm... Need a detox from last night? Get it here.

Zak H.Zak Hill: Delicious desserts with fresh fruit❕❕

Diversey River Bowl is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

5. Diversey River Bowl

8.5
2211 W Diversey Ave (at Logan Blvd), Chicago, IL
Bowling Alley · Bucktown · 39 tips and reviews

Philly G.Philly G: Bowling is fun. Beer tubes are good and inexpensive

Eric B.Eric Billimoria: The bartenders are what make this place great! Mandy and Jeni are the best!

TCTC: HALF ACRE ON TAP! #CHICAGOBREWS

The Cupcake Counter is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

6. The Cupcake Counter

7.6
229 W Madison St, Chicago, IL
Cupcake Shop · The Loop · 9 tips and reviews

greg m.greg m: anything with chocolate frosting. lemon cupcakes. red velvet.

Ann V.Ann Vileshin: I love this place, BUT about a year ago they decided to start charging $.50 for a box if you want just one cupcake! Otherwise, they wrap it in tissue and stick it in a paper baggy!

Samantha C.Samantha C.: Awesome intelligentsia coffee here!!!

Morrie O'Malley's Hot Dogs is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

7. Morrie O'Malley's Hot Dogs

7.6
3501 S Union Ave (at W 35th St), Chicago, IL
Hot Dog Joint · Bridgeport · 10 tips and reviews

Samantha R.Samantha Radick: The char steak sandwich is amazing! Even tho it has gotten a little smaller... =( The chocolate shake is also a must have!

Serious EatsSerious Eats: Here the hot dogs come fully loaded, with an extra raw cucumber thrown in for good measure. But that's just one item on this stand's massive menu.

RJ O.RJ OMalley: DO NOT put ketchup on your hot dog! Also, try the strip steak sandwich, its amazing.

Stella's Diner is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

8. Stella's Diner

7.6
3042 N Broadway St (at W Barry Ave), Chicago, IL
Diner · Lake View East · 69 tips and reviews

Vladimir S.Vladimir Shuvalov: While visiting Chicago for 3 days I been here 6 times. 3 breakfast, 3 suppers. Speaks for itself 😝😝 Try pancakes and milkshakes!

Ryan H.Ryan Hackett: Stuffed. French. Toast.

ChappyChappy: Their milkshakes bring this boy/man to the yard/diner.

Slim's is one of The 9 Best Places for Butterfingers in Chicago.

9. Slim's

7.5
2020 W Montrose Ave (Damen), Chicago, IL
Fast Food Restaurant · Ravenswood · 17 tips and reviews

Stephan G.Stephan Germain: I love the black bean burger here and the value is supreme. Curly fries are killer and they have super fast delivery.

Andy H.Andy Harrison: Perfect fries. Eat them.

joey m.joey mccusty: There's some BBQ sauce on the counter that tastes really good on the fries.