Anderson's Frozen Custard is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

1. Anderson's Frozen Custard

8.7
2634 Delaware Ave (in Delaware Consumer Square), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Delaware · 31 tips and reviews

Kevin v.Kevin van wagner: Carmel Apple crisp ice cream is amazing

DanielleDanielle: Gluten free ice cream sandwiches!!!

Clark D.Clark Dever: Nom nom nom, best ice cream in town. The roast beef sandwiches are also amazing. Fries are fresh and delicious!

Donut Kraze is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

2. Donut Kraze

8.5
406 Dingens St, Buffalo, NY
Donut Shop · Kaisertown · 9 tips and reviews

John M.John McKenzie: Try the peanut creme donut you won't be disappointed!

Christopher O.Christopher Ouimet: Awesome, fresh donuts and really good coffee. Plus they have free wifi.

Timothy M.Timothy Mittlefehldt II: Awesome donuts! THE place to go!

Parkside Candy is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

3. Parkside Candy

8.7
3208 Main St (Winspear Ave), Buffalo, NY
Dessert Shop · University · 12 tips and reviews

Ann J.Ann Johnnidis: Cute, old fashioned candy store with the best ice cream in Buffalo!!

Laketa C.Laketa C.: Have a delicious ice cream sundae in a traditional, old fashioned sundae dish at the counter! Pleasant environment too

Prosenjit B.Prosenjit Bhattacharya: This is my favorite dessert shop in Buffalo. Best salt water taffy and ice cream

Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

4. Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream

8.5
1900 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Buffalo · 5 tips and reviews

Chris B.Chris Barning: The North Park Sundae with Paula's Red Velvet Donut Ice Cream

Pat M.Pat Matisz: The Loganberry ice cream is to die for!!!!

Lucy S.Lucy Snell: Variety of unusual flavors and unique sundaes 🤗🤗🤗

Lexington Co-Op is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

5. Lexington Co-Op

8.9
807 Elmwood Ave (at Auburn Ave), Buffalo, NY
Grocery Store · Delaware - West Ferry · 37 tips and reviews

Jamie M.Jamie Markley: Try the chocolate chip cookies. $2.50 for 4. So worth it.

Sarah L.Sarah Lang: Fave vegan finds: Beyond Meat products, Squarebars & Larabars, Primal jerky, vegan choc chip cookies, Thai peanut wrap, Mediterranean hummus wrap, Ezekiel products, Daiya, Earth Balance, etc.

JoshJosh: Best chocolate cake?

The Chocolate Bar is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

6. The Chocolate Bar

7.2
114 W Chippewa St (in Hampton Inn & Suites), Buffalo, NY
Cocktail Bar · Central Business District · 41 tips and reviews

Thomas S.Thomas Schumacher: Coconut Macaroon Martini is amazing. Was not a martini guy until I tried it here.

Social YeahSocial Yeah: Known for their specialty desserts & cocktails... great for a girls night out or date night!

Lindsay B.Lindsay Benz: Cinnamon Icecream Sundae is amazing!

Ristorante Lombardo is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

7. Ristorante Lombardo

8.2
1198 Hertel Ave (at Virgil Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 17 tips and reviews

Steve P.Steve Poland: Desserts were delicious. Tiramisu, wow. Banana cream pie thing was likely the best, but I am a chocolate fan and thus the oreo pie was a grand slam!

Mike H.Mike Hayes: Amanda might be the best waitress ever. Not a bad thing on the menu. Feel a little full after dinner but still want to try dessert? Vanilla bean gelato! Sounds plain? It's far from it!

Steve P.Steve Poland: NB’s rec’s: Octopus is dope. Uovo en purgatorio pizza, Caesar salad made tableside, and then for dessert I love the frou frou cake and n gets the banoffe pie.

Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

8. Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffé

7.8
1292 Hertel Ave (at Crestwood Ave), Buffalo, NY
Italian Restaurant · North Park · 23 tips and reviews

Jennifer G.Jennifer Garrigan: I have never had anything I did not like from the dinners or desserts! Cheers!

Katie W.Katie Willman: Really good pizza and fantastic dessert.

Jewels B.Jewels Be: The scallops were perfectly done and the pasta portions are huge! Either share a plate or be ready to take half home in a doggie bag. The tiramisu is delicious!

Public Espresso + Coffee is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

9. Public Espresso + Coffee

9.0
391 Washington St (at Clinton St), Buffalo, NY
Coffee Shop · Central Business District · 23 tips and reviews

Joe R.Joe Russell: Smooth coffee and home made poptarts from Butter Block on Fridays.

Andrea D.Andrea Dzavik: Whiskey-orange glazed donut. Need I say more ? :)

Anthony G.Anthony Gomez: Great Espresso, friendly service & ModBar! The lobby is a great place to catch up on work or do some reading. Outlets, reliable wifi and some super cool chairs. You must try the Goat's Milk Cortado!

Canalside is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

10. Canalside

9.3
44 Prime St, Buffalo, NY
Event Space · Waterfront · 39 tips and reviews

Daniel S.Daniel Singer: Try the spongebob ice cream!!!!!!!!!!!

Anne ShirleyAnne Shirley: Love it here, its a great place to take a walk. It's so peaceful & there is good food, fun things to see & do. Be sure to climb the tower to the top- the views of the lake are gorgeous!

Ben T.Ben Tsujimoto: It's getting more and more awesome. Liberty hound, harbor concerts, Clinton's dish, sweet adirondack chairs -- I like where it's headed.

Oliver's is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

11. Oliver's

8.4
2095 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY
American Restaurant · Park Meadow · 20 tips and reviews

Stephen W.Stephen Watson: Great fasnachts on the dessert menu. Warm and airy.

Amnon B.Amnon B: Seafood risotto was amazing.swordfish was prepared beautifully and strawberry sorbet was excellent .Sunday wine at half price ...how lucky we are.

MC B.MC B: Great place for a nice meal. Put on your jackets gents and come on down. Really nice bar for a drink before. Outstanding varied menu. Sure to please all.

Shea's Performing Arts Center is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

12. Shea's Performing Arts Center

9.2
646 Main St (at W Tupper St), Buffalo, NY
Performing Arts Venue · Central Business District · 49 tips and reviews

Kylie D.Kylie Dekdebrun: Try the fresh chocolate chip cookies... A fitting dessert!

Nelson ..Nelson .: Eat the chocolate chip cookie!!! And be nice to the ushers , they volunteer.

Melissa B.Melissa Burgess: Not a bad seat in the house. Historic theatre with wonderful charm.. go for one show or get season tickets, either way - you can't go wrong.

The Phoenix is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

13. The Phoenix

7.6
269 Amherst St, Buffalo, NY
Gastropub · Black Rock · 13 tips and reviews

Niagara PopcornNiagara Popcorn: Celebrated my birthday dinner there last week. I loved the polenta fries, salmon with a sort of crust on it, and the tiramisu. This is a nice new addition to the Buffalo restaurant scene. Nice job!

Matthew A.Matthew Anthony: Buffalos new hidden gem. Food is unique and delicious. Try the blackened fish fry on Fridays and the phoenix tart for dessert.

Jennifer S.Jennifer Shantler: The White Silk Tart is a slice of heaven on a flaky crust. Totally melts in your mouth!

Betty's Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

14. Betty's Restaurant

8.9
370 Virginia St (at Cottage St), Buffalo, NY
Breakfast Spot · Allen · 60 tips and reviews

samanthasamantha: winter sqash tart is absolutely amazing. best meal I've had in awhile!!!!

Julia J.Julia J.S: Best brunch in buffalo- wonderful gluten free rolls and cookies!

Julia J.Julia J.S: Favorite brunch place in the city; creative menu with a unique specials menu every single day. Delicious omelets, and tasty desserts. Also have the best gluten-free buns in the city!

Hanna's Frosty Treats is one of The 15 Best Places for Desserts in Buffalo.

15. Hanna's Frosty Treats

7.6
140 Taunton Pl (at Colvin Ave), Buffalo, NY
Ice Cream Parlor · North Park · 9 tips and reviews

Megan H.Megan H.: S'mores sundae!

Jeromy A.Jeromy Allsop: Best custard!!!

John M.John Miller: They always have one no-sugar-added choice, and rotate it frequently.