Highland Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

1. Highland Bakery

8.6
655 Highland Ave NE (at Sampson St NE), Atlanta, GA
Bakery · Old Fourth Ward · 228 tips and reviews

Joel C.Joel Corpus: The only place I carb out in Atlanta! Top items are the Peanut Butter French Toast, Sweet Potato Biscuits, Jalapeno Cheddar Foccicia Bread and the Fried Chicken Benedict. Uh-mazing!

ROC House Women's Fitness SpaROC House Women's Fitness Spa: Everyone should try the Peanut Butter French Toast at least once. A dangerously large serving! Be sure to hit the gym afterward.

Ashley K.Ashley Keyes: I love the Peanut Butter French Toast & Fried Chicken Egg Benedict!

CamiCakes is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

2. CamiCakes

9.2
2221 Peachtree Rd NE, Atlanta, GA
Cupcake Shop · Peachtree Hills · 89 tips and reviews

Jennifer O.Jennifer Overturf: Chocolate peanut butter cup cake and coffee... Need I say more?

Kristen L.Kristen Leigh: Peanut Butter Chocolate is THE BEST!!

Ava R.Ava R.: Elivs even has a cupcake here sometimes - think Banana and Peanut Butter

Sublime Doughnuts is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

3. Sublime Doughnuts

9.0
535 10th St NW (Hemphill Ave NW), Atlanta, GA
Donut Shop · 155 tips and reviews

Ashley JoyAshley Joy: Kamal is the doughnut master! The Reese's peanut butter cup is to die for...

Sabur T.Sabur Taylor: Maple bacon cheddar, strawberries and cream, and the Reese's peanut butter are my favorites. #gourmetdonuts

DailyCandyDailyCandy: Chef/owner Kamal Grant changed the city’s donut game; the shop reigns supreme with ridiculous delicacies like fresh strawberries and cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, and the beloved A-town cream.

Highland Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

4. Highland Bakery

7.5
3353 Peachtree Rd NE Ste 150, Atlanta, GA
Bakery · Lenox · 53 tips and reviews

Alyssa G.Alyssa Gee: Try the Peanut Butter French Toast:)!!!

Jonathan G.Jonathan Gaby: Peanut Butter French Toast. Rich but very good!

Ashley JoyAshley Joy: Great brunch, especially the peanut butter french toast! I don't like bananas and you can get it without!

Morelli's Gourmet Ice Cream is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

5. Morelli's Gourmet Ice Cream

9.1
749 Moreland Ave SE (at Ormewood Ave. SE), Atlanta, GA
Ice Cream Parlor · Ormewood Park · 92 tips and reviews

Thomas S.Thomas Snowden: Their ice cream birthday cakes are ridiculously good. I had a chocolate cake with peanut butter chocolate chip ice cream on one side and banana cream pie on the other. I drool just thinking about it.

Village SmoothieVillage Smoothie: I love love love the peanut butter chocolate and any other that has a peanut butter chocolate mix! Amazing ice cream! Amazing!

DailyCandyDailyCandy: You dream of peanut butter swirled with licorice and marshmallows. Luckily, Morelli’s Gourmet Ice Cream fields customer suggestions and then whips up new flavors each month.

Grindhouse Killer Burgers is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

6. Grindhouse Killer Burgers

8.9
209 Edgewood Ave SE (Inside the Sweet Auburn Market), Atlanta, GA
Burger Joint · Georgia State University · 41 tips and reviews

Brian W.Brian Wong: Rediculous burgers and get the malted peanut butter choc milk shake

Wendy G.Wendy G: Free parking for 90 mins with validation, limited seating so get there before lunch and dinner primetime. Choc peanut butter shake is really good!!!

Jesse H.Jesse Heady: Perhaps the best burgers in Atlanta. Grindhouse style, fries, Orange Fanta, and retro classics on the projector. It really can't get much better.

Five Daughters Bakery is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

7. Five Daughters Bakery

8.6
675 Ponce de Leon Ave NE Ste N143, Atlanta, GA
Donut Shop · Midtown · 8 tips and reviews

Aaron F.Aaron Fowler: The malted peanut butter donut is delicious!

Kevin S.Kevin Sedlacek: Probably the single best donut company in the US. New seasonal donuts every month and a fantastic selection of staples. Highly recommend this to everyone.

Igal G.Igal Ghitelman: Donuts, any kind!

The Vortex Bar & Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

8. The Vortex Bar & Grill

8.8
438 Moreland Ave NE (at Euclid Ave NE), Atlanta, GA
Bar · Little Five Points · 313 tips and reviews

Alvin W.Alvin W: Elvis Burger. Don't get turned off cuz it's got peanut butter, fried bananas, and BACON!!!

B Culture MediaB Culture Media: The Elvis burger is only for the adventurous. The peanut butter and banana combo is a classic but The Vortex puts a whole new spin on this classic treat.

Justin F.Justin Frechette: Excellent food and atmosphere. The Elvis burger with peanut butter was really good!

Café Intermezzo is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

9. Café Intermezzo

8.6
1065 Peachtree St NE Ste 2 (11th Street), Atlanta, GA
Café · Midtown · 144 tips and reviews

Marybeth B.Marybeth Bush: Very cute atmosphere, perfect place to relax and wind down. I highly recommend the chocolate, peanut butter cake!

Brooks S.Brooks Smith: Get anything with peanut butter! Desserts are so good!

Bethany L.Bethany Looi: Loved this cafe in midtown! It feels just like one you'd find in Europe with delicious cakes (try carrot cake!) and great atmosphere.

Agave is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

10. Agave

8.5
242 Boulevard SE (at Carroll St), Atlanta, GA
Mexican Restaurant · Cabbagetown · 103 tips and reviews

GPNAGPNA: Local Lust: Everything is great! Keep coming back until you have eaten everything on the menu at least once. Always finish with Peanut Butter Pie. It's got a kick!

Sara M.Sara McGlothlin: Get: meatloaf, peanut butter pie. Don't get: guacamole, mango margarita.

GPNAGPNA: Everything is great! Keep coming back until you have eaten everything on the menu at least once. Always finish with Peanut Butter Pie. It's got a kick!

Mellow Mushroom is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

11. Mellow Mushroom

8.1
1770 Peachtree St NW (at 26th St), Atlanta, GA
Pizzeria · Brookwood · 36 tips and reviews

'Nico L.'Nico Losado: The peanut butter cookies are so good

Melissa AshleyMelissa Ashley: Never a disappointment! Changed thee menu around, but added some great new pies. The "special to the location" pizzas sound amazing! Try the Meatball Ricotta pizza. Yum!

Scott D.Scott Day: The Double-wide (aka. Meat Sweats) is LEGIT! Get it while it lasts.

Souper Jenny is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

12. Souper Jenny

8.4
130 W Paces Ferry Rd NW (near Slaton Dr NW), Atlanta, GA
Soup Spot · Buckhead · 52 tips and reviews

Tad S.Tad Spencer: Enjoyed the brisket chili and the tomato soup with a hint of rosemary (very interesting). Love love love the peanut butter cookies!! Had to stop at one!

Cherry blossom ░ ☼ ♥ レo√乇 ♥ ☼ ░❤¸•´¯`☆Cherry blossom ░ ☼ ♥ レo√乇 ♥ ☼ ░❤¸•´¯`☆: I believe that true friendship grows, even over the longest distance....

Dwayne K.Dwayne Kilbourne: I heard that it is Cash or Check only... no form of credit/debit card is taken! Interesting!

Folk Art Restaurant is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

13. Folk Art Restaurant

9.0
465 N Highland Ave NE (at Colquitt Ave NE), Atlanta, GA
American Restaurant · Inman Park · 88 tips and reviews

Chandra B.Chandra Buck: The peanut butter and banana french toast is HEAVEN!! The pb is sooooo goood

Adam B.Adam Bueb: This place is quickly becoming one of my favorite brunch and lunch places in atlanta!!! Their food is amazing and they have excellent drinks!!

Liz T.Liz Turcotte: Folk Southern Fried with eggs over easy is amazing and the mimosas are so tasty! Tip your servers!!

R. Thomas' Deluxe Grill is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

14. R. Thomas' Deluxe Grill

8.7
1812 Peachtree St NW (Palisades Rd), Atlanta, GA
Vegan and Vegetarian Restaurant · Buckhead · 225 tips and reviews

Michael H.Michael Hubbard: The peanut butter chocolate pie is to die for!

ALESHA B.ALESHA BELL: Get the peanut butter and jelly smoothie

Steph M.Steph McBrien: Cajun sauté to eat and cinnamon girl to drink! Perfect!

Cook Out is one of The 15 Best Places for Peanut Butter in Atlanta.

15. Cook Out

8.0
403 Moreland Ave SE (at Faith Ave SE), Atlanta, GA
Burger Joint · Ormewood Park · 88 tips and reviews

Paul G.Paul Goggin: Great peanut butter banana shake! So thick you can't use a straw. Good price and value overall. Very crowded but moved relatively quickly. Not enough seating.

Chris S.Chris Styles: The peanut butter n banana shake is good... but thats the only one ive tried so far...

Patricia A.Patricia Allen: If you're from North Carolina....you already know! Cook-out is The Business! YUMMY milkshakes, good pulled pork sandwiches, wonderful grilled chicken and hamburgers...the list goes on.